Should Christian farmers butcher an animal following the halal practices?

You are here

Should Christian farmers butcher an animal following the halal practices?

Login or Create an Account

With a UCG.org account you will be able to save items to read and study later!

Sign In | Sign Up

×

Halal-certified foods, which are prepared a certain way according to Islamic teaching, are becoming more popular every year. Consumers can rest assured that meats slaughtered according to halal practices are “clean” according to Leviticus 11. In addition, halal also certifies that as much blood as possible has been drained out during slaughter. These are both biblically correct principles. However, there is more to the issue.

Information posted online by Muslim organizations such as the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA) states that “halal certification” involves a blessing by a Muslim representative prior to slaughter. It also appears that the actual slaughtering needs to be done by a Muslim.

Let’s first consider scriptural principles. The New Testament discusses an issue of the first century regarding whether or not to eat meats that had been offered to a pagan idol. What Paul wrote on that topic can provide guidance on halal foods. Please see our study guide titled, “What Does the Bible Teach About Clean and Unclean Meats?”

In the chapter, "Does the New Testament Abolish Meat Distinctions?"  the study aid states, “Paul explained that ‘an idol is nothing’ (1 Corinthians 8:4), clarifying that it was not intrinsically harmful to eat meats that had been sacrificed to an idol. That an animal had been sacrificed to a pagan god had no bearing on whether the meat was suitable for food.”

The study aid discusses 1 Corinthians 8 on the subject of meats that had been offered to pagan idols. The apostle Paul explained that offering meats to idols does nothing to change the nutritional value of that meat—and it can be eaten if it is “clean” meat according to God’s food laws of Leviticus 11.

However, some in Corinth were weak in conscience. That means that eating clean meats that had been offered to a pagan god was offensive to some of the members. In this situation, Paul taught that it was wrong to do anything that might cause them to stumble (1 Corinthians 8:12-13).

Today, nearly 2,000 years after Paul’s time, the same thing can happen due to how meats are slaughtered. Many foods are offered to various gods during the slaughtering process. Halal food laws govern what is slaughtered, how it is slaughtered, and for whom or what it is offered. So do kosher laws for Jews.

We can apply Paul’s statement in 1 Corinthians 8:4 as a principle. Truly the “idol is nothing.” From this we can conclude that meat today is not altered in any way even when it is slaughtered according to halal or kosher laws. The same is true for any practice among peoples around the world where clean meats may be offered to a god, idol or to nature itself.

Foods that are marked halal or kosher will have been blessed by a cleric or priest or rabbi. That does not mean we cannot enjoy the roast, chicken or fish—as long as they are clean meats. The Bible also teaches us that “whatever is not from faith is sin” (Romans 14:23). If eating foods that are marked as being acceptable according to halal or kosher laws bothers a person, he or she should not consume it or try to coerce others to eat it.

The question above gets into the area of whether a Christian can participate in the regulations included in halal slaughtering. The greatest challenge for a Christian will be the required blessing prior to slaughtering an animal. ISNA states that slaughter is to be done by a Muslim after stating in the Arabic language, “In the name of Allah the greatest.” Paying fees for halal certification are involved.

It should be understood that the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob is not exactly the same as the god recognized in the Islamic faith as Allah. To encourage Islamic halal prayers to be conducted on the farm should be carefully thought through. Even though the meat itself is still “clean” to eat afterwards, the person may be participating in the ritual more than is appropriate for a Christian.

In making a decision, it is important to study scriptural passages such as Romans 14:1-23; 1 Corinthians 8:1-13; 1 Corinthians 10:14-33, and 2 Corinthians 6:14-18, and to pray about this. The farmer should ask God to guide and inspire the decision. It is good to back away from the situation at hand and honestly consider the question, “What am I responsible for before God?” Jesus gave the first and great commandment in Matthew 22:37 by saying, “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.”

The United Church of God does not have an official policy regarding whether a Christian can participate in halal certification. Only the person knows his or her own conscience before God. We recommend researching the topic thoroughly.

You might also be interested in...

Comments

  • Rajah Ahmeed

    As an American living in America, it is very difficult to follow God's instructions for us because the White Americans of the histories of the US government whom infiltrated the country have not respected nor instituted God's laws as being primary law in the US.

    The White Americans did not originally have the testimony of God like those in the Middle East, the Europeans were warned of God's work and held translations of God's Word.

    As Christopher Columbus and George Washington "discovered" "America" for Europeans; and then they robbed and murdered and enslaved the Native Americans and Africans up to this day. As the Native and Black Americans warred themselves out of that bondage, the

    So the many races of people living in America are being

  • Rajah Ahmeed

    Christians, non-Jews and non-Muslims, must also get to know the facts of Islam and Judaism, before denying God's guidance to us; it is safe to protect God's guidance to us from deceivers, atheists, false teachers and language artists using God's name or image in vain. Islam and Christianity is referenced from Judaism; Judaism is referenced from an older worship of God, in which I did not yet confirm the name of that "religion" because of the fossiling of this ancient but sacred information. However, it is known that, during several long distance generations, God appeared to different men from different languages, races and lands but amongst those with the faith of God. Giving them the proper guidance and information for the way He made our bodies and spirits. Our God authorized leaders of God's way and law: Adam, Noah, Abraham, Lot, David, Moses, Jesus Christ, Muhammad. Living in different generations, sitting centuries apart of one another, relayed and referencing the Lord God's instructions and teachings to mankind, made it clear. Since Jews and Muslims have strict dietary laws from God for slaughtering and eating meat, Christians and non-believers must obey God's way too.

  • IsmailB

    I would like to point out a mistake in the 3rd to the last paragraph.
    "It should be understood that the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob is not exactly the same as the god recognized in the Islamic faith as Allah." This isn't true. The God of Abraham and all of the prophets, Peace Be Upon Them, ALL WORSHIP THE SAME GOD. The name of God is Al illah (The One True God) and the name the Muslim (One who submits his entire will and way of God) is Allah. The Qur'an extols Abraham as a model, an exemplar, obedient and not an idolator. ... Muslims maintain that Abraham further asked God to bless both the lines of his progeny, of Ismail (Ishmael) and Ishaq (Isaac), and to keep all of his descendants in the protection of God. As a matter of fact at the Holy Mosque in Mecca there is a station called Maqamul Ibrahim thats a special rite of our Pilgrimage there to show respect to Abraham for 1st erecting that 1st house to God for worship. This is what Allah says in the Quran: Who can be better in religion than one who submits his whole self to Allah, does good, and follows the way of Abraham the true in Faith? For Allah did takeFor Allah did take Abraham for a friend.
    — Sura 4 ,Ayat 125

  • tomsmith0987654

    This article is slightly wrong about the Muslim slaughtering. I want to point out in the 2nd paragraph in last sentence, "It also appears that the actual slaughtering needs to be done by a Muslim.", that the Muslim slaughtering can be done by Muslims, Jews or Christians with the condition that when slaughtering the animal, they MUST say "In the name of Allah", in Arabic "Bismillah". The slaughtering cannot be done by any other faiths including atheists. Only by Muslims, Christians or Jews. Hope this clears the view about Islam slaughtering a bit.

  • Murielle

    Very helpful article! Thank you.

  • Join the conversation!

    Log in or register to post comments