Did a Good God Create an Evil World?

You are here

Did a Good God Create an Evil World?

Login or Create an Account

With a UCG.org account you will be able to save items to read and study later!

Sign In | Sign Up

×

We humans have thought up many an explanation to try to explain the phenomenon of evil. For many people, the idea that a devil incites human beings to deeds of lust and cruelty is absurd, nothing more than a fairy tale. A common view is that people commit atrocities because they themselves were victims of abuse.

Most psychologists discount the possibility of the existence of a devil, but a few years ago one psychological counselor squarely faced the problem of evil. He did so because he was retained by the judicial system to interview men who were accused of the most depraved acts. He entered the inner sanctum of jails and prisons to interview prisoners who had committed atrocities against their fellow human beings.

A state supreme court had ruled that accused killers must have access to professional counseling before the state could put them on trial. Prosecutors could make public only evidence that was deemed favorable to the defendants. The jury and the trial judge couldn't even listen to evidence that reflected unfavorably upon the accused.

Under the cloak of confidentiality, the counselor often heard vile tales vividly described by these depraved killers. Many of the stories contained evidence that would remain forever hidden to all but the psychologist, including confessions to hideous crimes as well as accounts of the pathetic pleas of victims in the moments before their deaths.

Stifling his inner revulsion, the counselor listened intently to graphic details of bloody torture and the beastly, systematic thoughts of the tormentor as he satiated his twisted, brutal appetites at the expense of someone's wife or child.

After emerging from behind the confining walls, this psychologist found himself pondering a question that the sum of his professional training had taught him to reject: Does evil exist?

The source of evil

Many of the educated of our society reject the idea, but the Bible is insistent that evil exists. The biblical writers presented evil in the form of a decadent prince of demons, called Satan, whose primary purpose is to destroy humankind.

Conventional wisdom holds that people commit atrocities because they themselves were victims of abuse. But millions of people grow up in unhappy circumstances. They live in poverty, are targets of parental violence and suffer the consequences of humanity's imperfections. But they do not grow into despots or mass murderers.

Why, then, do some people choose to vent their frustrations by hating and abusing others, although most do not?

The Bible shows us that a hateful spirit being lives who beckons humans to follow his way of destruction, abuse and murder.

We first read of this creature in the book of Genesis, when he appeared on the scene in the Garden of Eden in the form of a serpent. He tempted the first man and woman to disobey God by eating forbidden fruit (Genesis 3:1-13). This first disobedience by mankind launched the human race on its course of chronic and habitual disobedience (Romans 5:12).

A little later this hateful being, Satan the devil, tempted Cain to commit the first act of murder. Cain, the firstborn son of Adam and Eve, became angry, and his rage clouded his judgment (Genesis 4:6). God challenged Cain to rise above his wrath: "If you do well, will you not be accepted? And if you do not do well, sin lies at the door. And its desire is for you, but you should rule over it" (Genesis 4:7).

Cain responded by killing Abel (verse 8). Cain could have resisted the temptation to do harm to his brother, but he didn't. Anyone who murders or commits other violent acts has simply failed to subdue his nature, as Cain failed to subdue his. Those who seek an explanation for violent acts fail to understand the enormous influence Satan has on the thoughts, attitudes and actions of mankind.

Earlier this year, after a gunman in Dunblane, Scotland, shot and killed 16 small schoolchildren and their teacher and wounded another 12 youngsters, a distraught school official summed up the tragedy: "Evil visited us yesterday, and we don't know why."

Some succumb to Satan

People who are aware, through the study of the Bible, that Satan exists know why the Dunblane tragedy happened. At least they understand the existence of evil in a broad sense. Students of the Bible grasp that Satan actually searches the earth for people who will follow him and succumb to murderous impulses because of their frustration with life. They understand that Satan entices some to "devour" anyone who gets in their way as would a vicious beast (1 Peter 5:8). These victims have themselves been devoured by Satan, who has enticed them into a life of cruelty and utter worthlessness.

Satan's influence is manifest in the form of other, equally hideous, acts. In June of this year a California jury convicted a 42-year-old former convict of murdering a 12-year-old girl. The perpetrator had spent most of his life behind bars and had been out of prison only three months when he entered the child's bedroom and abducted her at knifepoint in the presence of two playmates. He apparently had stalked the youngster and had planned his crime well beforehand.

Evidence at the trial established a pattern of sexual assault against women before he selected this child as his next victim. When the jury foreman read the guilty verdict, the defendant responded by making an obscene gesture with both hands.

The world is filled with violence too savage to attribute to mere human evil. Through thousands of years of recorded history, Satan has influenced human beings to perpetrate the unimaginable against other individuals and, in wartime, against whole nations and peoples. The recent war in Bosnia is only the latest such example. The atrocities of World War II are still vividly remembered by many.

Both the Bible and secular history witness that, from the dawn of civilization, man's history depicts a bloody chain of inhuman cruelty in times of war. The ancient Assyrians, for example, recorded in stone a ghastly, graphic record of human mutilation.

Timely answer to a timeless question

Why does God allow evil in the world? Anyone who has ever suffered tragedy wonders about this. Philosophers and churchmen have repeatedly asked the question. Theologian Harold Kushner, in his 1981 book When Bad Things Happen to Good People, rephrased the question: "Why do bad things happen to good people?"

Everyone asks this question at one time or another-theologians, philosophers, historians and even physicists. Let's look at some of their answers.

English theologian Edwin Hatch once put it: "How did a God who was almighty as well as beneficent come to create what is imperfect and evil?" (The Influence of Greek Ideas and Usages Upon the Christian Church, 1995, Peabody, Massachusetts, p. 194). Dr. Hatch described the quandary addressed by the early Church after the apostolic era. The apostles of Christ never wrestled with this issue, but those who came later did.

One possible explanation was offered by the gnostic Marcion early in the second century. Marcion believed that "two rival Gods existed: One was the tyrannical creator and lawgiver of the Old Testament, the other the unknown God of love and mercy who sent Jesus to purchase salvation from the creator God" (Webster Encyclopedia, one-volume edition, p. 561).

In Marcion's view, the lawgiver God was responsible for the existence of pain and evil, and the work of the Savior was to deliver the world from the pain and evil caused by God. This heretical outlook was modified and refined by others but took root in the body of subsequent church doctrine, where its influence has fostered frequent confusion.

Some historians have addressed the seeming contradiction of a world created by God but replete with evil. Englishman Arnold Toynbee noted that "one of the conclusions that have been drawn by human spectators of the moral evil of the Universe is that this chamber of horrors cannot be any God's handiwork" (A Study of History, abridged version, 1957, Vol. XII, p. 300).

a good God create a bad world? If so, why would He do such a thing? If not, then how did evil and evil acts come to exist in a world created by God?

Toynbee saw that the Christian "finds himself compelled to choose between two . . . alternatives, both of which are grievously disconcerting: Either the God who is Love must be the creator of a manifestly ailing Universe, or the Universe must have been created by another God who is not the God of Love" (ibid.).

Scientists ponder

Scientists study the physical realm, but some have pondered the imponderable. Physicist Paul Davies considers another side of the good-vs.-evil argument. He considers the issue of why God, if He truly is all-powerful, does not simply intervene and stop all evil.

"Is God free to prevent evil?" Davies wonders. "If he is omnipotent, yes. Why then does He fail to do so" (God and The New Physics, 1983, p. 143). Davies has a point: Why doesn't God just ban all evil? If Satan is responsible, why doesn't God in some way simply stop the devil?

The view of an atheist

Perhaps the main reason some people are atheists is that they cannot satisfactorily reconcile the problem of a good God and an evil world. Julian Huxley wrote about the existence of evil, that "its existence is a challenge to God's moral character" (Religion Without Revelation , 1957, p. 109). Huxley concluded that divine revelation and a divine Revelator do not exist.

We find no shortage of eloquent descriptions of the dynamics of this problem. But we need answers. Mankind has concocted explanations. Some people have concluded that God doesn't exist. Some adopt Marcion's belief of a Godhead in conflict. Some man-made explanations are totally lacking in accuracy, but others give a glimpse of the biblical truth. For example, Toynbee writes that "God's love is the source of Man's freedom," and "every challenge can be regarded equally as a call from God or as a temptation by the Devil" (A Study of History, p. 300). Professor Toynbee has touched on two truths. The first is that God allows evil in the world as a consequence of free will.

God gives free will, or personal choice, to every human being.

The second truth Toynbee mentions is that there is a devil, a being adept at tempting people to make all the wrong choices (Matthew 4:3).

The author of violence

Jesus confirmed that the devil seduces people into committing atrocities. We saw earlier that Cain was the first human who killed, but Jesus showed that murderous attitudes begin with Satan. In Christ's day jealous men wanted to kill the very Son of God (John 8:40). Later these deceived and deceitful zealots succeeded.

Jesus clearly identified the source of their evil motivations: "You are of your father the devil, and the desires of your father you want to do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and does not stand in the Truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaks a lie, he speaks from his own resources, for he is a liar and the father of it" (verse 44).

The devil's influence is powerful and pervasive. Through the centuries, people's belief in the existence of a devil has waxed and waned. Europeans devoutly believed in him in the Middle Ages and throughout the Renaissance. But in modern times the idea of a deceiving devil went out of style.

On this subject, however, the only information that really matters is what the Bible provides. From Genesis to Revelation, the Bible tells us in the most solemn terms that the devil exists as a powerful being. Satan and his cohorts, the demons, are mentioned more frequently in Scripture than even the Holy Spirit.

The devil is destructive

A good word to describe the tactics and nature of Satan is destructive. Satan makes mayhem and murder, and he has been at it since the dawn of human history. The Bible reveals that at the close of this age Satan will still be actively attempting to destroy humanity. Revelation 9:11 calls him Abaddon and Apollyon, names that mean "destruction" and "destroyer."

He has many accomplices-demons who share his frame of mind. During His earthly ministry, Jesus Christ encountered a man possessed by many demons (Mark 5:1-15). Mark's Gospel account describes the man's bizarre actions. Night and day "he was in the mountains and in the tombs, crying out and cutting himself with stones" (verse 9).

The demons drove this miserable man to self-mutilation. Jesus felt compassion for the man and ordered the demons away. They then entered a herd of swine and drove the defenseless animals over a cliff into the sea (verse 13).

After reading and believing the biblical account, many have correctly concluded that evil in God's creation exists because God gives mankind free will and that Satan's deception is at the root of the suffering of human beings.

But believers in God still wonder why their Creator allows Satan's seemingly senseless ways of destruction to continue unabated. After the senseless murders of the innocent children at Dunblane, headmaster Ron Taylor lamented, "We don't understand it, and I don't think we ever will."

The origin of Satan

The Bible, however, tells why. It describes the beginning of Satan and why God allows him to continue to exist.

Satan was once a brilliant and powerful "covering cherub" (Ezekiel 28:16). Through rebellion against God, he corrupted himself and became Satan-whose very name means adversary. He is so labeled because he became the adversary of God Himself and the enemy of all good.

We do not know when Satan rebelled, but his insurrection occurred at a distant time before the creation of man. "How you are fallen from heaven, O Lucifer, son of the morning! How you are cut down to the ground, you who weakened the nations!" (Isaiah 14:12).

This is an amazing statement from the book of Isaiah with dual meaning. It applies at once to the wicked, Satan-dominated king of Babylon as well as to Satan himself. Jesus, referring to this event, said He "saw Satan fall like lightning from heaven" (Luke 10:18). Satan had determined to undermine and thwart every plan and purpose of God, beginning in the Garden of Eden with his temptation of Adam and Eve.

But this still doesn't explain why God has allowed Satan to continue.

There is a reason, an astonishing one, that we can understand when we realize God's plan for humanity. It is simply that God's purpose is to give mankind eternal life. This is why Jesus Christ came and died. God's gift to us "is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord" (Romans 6:23).

Before we can inherit eternal life, we have to be tested. "Blessed is the man who endures temptation; for when he has been proved, he will receive the crown of life which the Lord has promised to those who love Him" (James 1:12).

God's reasoning for testing us is to give us the chance to resist and overcome the temptation to do evil.

All humans, when they sin, fall under the same sentence God pronounced upon Adam and Eve. That sentence is death! All have sinned (Romans 3:23) and come under the death penalty until they repent, because the "wages of sin is death" (Romans 6:23). This is the condition in which we remain until we turn to God in humble repentance and accept Jesus Christ as our personal savior.

Satan is the ruler of the world by virtue of his pervasive influence (2 Corinthians 4:4). He has deceived the whole world (Revelation 12:9). This is why the earth's governments, dominated by evil regimes, can so readily gravitate to the dark side.

The meaning of the Day of Atonement

The Day of Atonement depicts the triumph of good over evil, of Jesus Christ over Satan and his legions of demons. In Leviticus 16 God gave instructions to the people of Israel concerning a ceremony He told them to perform every year on this Holy Day. The high priest was to select two goats, which were to symbolically bear the nation's sins. "One was killed as a sin offering; the other was sent off into the desert to bear away the sins of the people into an uninhabited place" (Expositor's Bible Commentary, Vol. 2, p. 588).

The first goat, which was slain (verse 15), prefigured the crucified Jesus Christ, killed to pay the penalty for the sins of mankind (John 1:29).

The second goat is called "the scapegoat" in some Bible translations (Leviticus 16:8, New King James Version) and Azazel in the original Hebrew. The Azazel goat represents Satan. Some scholars identify Azazel as the name of a demon inhabiting the wilderness (Interpreters Dictionary of the Bible, Vol. 1, p. 326).

In the ceremony of Leviticus 16 Satan is symbolically made to bear responsibility for the sins of humanity (verse 22) because of the deception he foisted upon men. Revelation 20 describes the future fulfillment of the event depicted by this solemn ceremony. When Jesus Christ returns to earth, He will immediately expel Satan from his position of influence over the world. Christ will place the devil into a condition of restraint and will lift the devil's cloak of deception (Revelation 20:1-3).

Jesus' act of deliverance prepares the way for "the restoration of all things" (Acts 3:21). God's servants "since the world began" have preached this prophesied wonderful world of tomorrow (same verse). Christ will usher in a perfect world, a setting in which every innocent child will be protected from harm (Isaiah 11:8-9). God will eradicate from this world the appalling evil we see around us, and no devil will be there to tempt mankind. Jesus Christ will bring in a world in which acts of love and obedience toward God, on the part of everyone, will result in a society that will always reward good and a world that ever restrains evil. God will put an end to the brutalization of women and the slaughter of little children and men. The great events depicted by the Day of Atonement will at last make love and peace a reality. 

You might also be interested in...

In the wake of the New York and Washington, D.C., suicide bombings, we need to...

Comments

  • Ivan Veller

    Hello Barry,

    We in the UCG stand with you in our extreme skepticism of the Catholic "'doctrine of 'original sin,' in which all humans are'" [presumed to be] "'born not only with a predisposition to sinful behavior, but with an inherently sinful nature. The [supposed] result is that every person is born deserving eternal damnation, whether or not they have actually committed a sin yet.'" http://www.ucg.org/commentary/human-nature-what-it/

    By contrast, we teach that children are "born with a neutral nature—tabula rasa," since it is from experience that humans derive "all the materials of reason" necessary to discern right from wrong (John Locke, 1690, "Essay Concerning Human Understanding"). While a geneticist such as Dr. Robert Plomin might approach the question in a different way (evocative gene-environment correlations in longitudinal developmental twin studies, for instance), this is my own formative conception of morality's formation post conception. http://www.ucg.org/booklet/transforming-your-life-process-conversion/what-sin/whats-wrong-our-human-nature/

    I am also in favor of rigorous, self-critical analysis--such as insistence on multiple strands of better & more appropriately standardized evidence: http://www.ucg.org/science/god-science-and-bible-scholars-fraud-dating-disaster-neanderthals/

    Also see http://www.ucg.org/science/serious-problems-dating-methods/

    I remain skeptical of argon dating’s failure to adequately take into account the possibility of argon contamination. For instance, Ardipithecus ramidus (Aramis, Ethiopia, 2009) - "the oldest known skeleton of a potential human ancestor” - was found sandwiched between layers of volcanic ash argon dated to be a wizened 4.4 million years old.

    (1) Gibbons (2009). “A new kind of ancestor: Ardipithecus unveiled.” Science: 326 (2 Oct. 2009), p. 36.

    And yet, mica (a common crustal mineral), when heated to 740°-860°C under high Argon pressure for a mere 3 to 10.5 hours, yields a radiometric argon age of up to 5 billion years (2)--0.6 billion years older than Ardi.

    (2) T.B. Karpinskaya, I.A. Ostrovskiy and L.L. Shanin, "Synthetic Introduction of Argon into Mica at High Pressures and Temperatures," Isu Akad Nauk S.S.S.R. Geology Series, 8 (1961): pp. 87-89. Cited in Snelling, A. A. 1999. “Potassium-Argon and Argon-Argon Dating of Crustal Rocks and the Problem of Excess Argon.” Acts & Facts: 28 (3).

  • KARS

    Hello Barry,
    To understand God is to read our Holy Bibles from cover to cover over one year. Lots of us don't really know God our Father.
    He made his angels first, then us. One of God's prized angels turned his back on his/our creator. And when this beautiful angel turned his back on God and rebelled; a great conflict began.
    Mr. Horner has been explaining how this fallen angel named Satan, has been causing God our Father trouble for a very long time. Since before man was created Satan has been nothing but trouble for our God.
    When God made us human beings,Satan was there in the Garden of Eden to mess up God our Father's plans and lied to Eve. However, God already had a backup plan.If man ate of the Tree of the Knowledge of good and evil; then the Word of God would come.

    This Word of God interacted with the people since Adam and Eve left the Garden of Eden. When you read the history of the human race before the flood, you will read about Enoch and how he walked with the LORD. As you continue to read through the Old Testament you will read how Abraham gave a tenth of all he had and gave it to Melchezidek, King of Salem this was the Word of God taking care of his creation.

    Well, when it came time for him to be born, He had to become human so he could save mankind from death by bringing us the ressurection from the dead. God told Joseph by an angel to call the the Word of God Jesus. We know him today by the name of Jesus Christ.

    Barry it takes a lifetime to learn who we are, why we are here, who God our Father is and His Only Begotten Son. The teachers of United Church of God are introducing you to the Holy Bible and the God Family of heaven above. It is our own responsibility to open up our Bibles and not only read them but teach ourselves God's truths. In this lesson Mr. Hornor is teaching us about God the Father, His Son, and our enemy Satan the Devil (the fallen angel). Mr. Hornor is teaching how Satan uses people to do very bad things.
    Some of the things you said are topics for other lessons. Like your statement about "eternal damnation". To learn about this would be another lesson.
    If you are truly interested in learning more. Then take your computer mouse up to the tool bar above and place it over the word "Library". A drop down menu will appear. There you will have a box named: "Booklets". There you will find answers to many questions.

  • dickson

    God gave every human the freedom and has never forced His laws on us, but the right to chose to follow him or the devil.

  • Barry

    Why do "God" make all Baby`s from Birth as Evil and is taught to live in Fear and Blackmail to force you to "Love" Him/Her or suffer eternal damnation. This situation is impossible for me to believe and "God" only appeared on the Scene "2000" years ago.
    Where was he for the Millions upon Millions of years that Humankind has existed on this Earth.
    "God" is supposed to be "Perfect" yet all his Humankind is imperfectly made, Where did He/She go wrong in the recipe, He/She must have had a Wry sense of humour and till up to today He/She sits there LAUGHING at the stupidity of Humankind. And why would the "Creator" want Humankind to be at the same Intelligence level as Animals before the Eating of the Fruit of Knowledge to give Humans Intelligence and the ability to reason.
    "God" will have to do better than that to have Intelligent People to follow him. My Faith in myself and my Brain Power is my Miracle Maker and my "God". The above Article has so many truths and the "Bible" is written for the fool that do not want to use their Intelligence and sane reasoning.
    "2000" years for "God" to show His/Her Presence. Absolutely Laughable and that is when the Roman Catholic Religion Started and that was only to ENSLAVE People with FEAR. Absolutely Laughable and take note, I am Kind and generous to others and try to live so that others have a good opinion of me.

    "YOU ARE WHAT OTHERS THINK OF YOU"

  • Join the conversation!

    Log in or register to post comments